{
  "id": "rel_graham_supports_graves",
  "relation": "supports",
  "to": "prop_us_mv_graves_rental_owner",
  "note": "The Graves Amendment is valid and preempts § 388 vicarious liability of commercial lessors in actions commenced on or after August 10, 2005.",
  "valid_from": null,
  "valid_to": null,
  "passages": [
    {
      "source": "src_courtlistener_graham_v_dunkley",
      "locator": "50 AD3d at 58",
      "text": "The section applies to all actions commenced on or after August 10, 2005 ... and has been enforced as preempting the vicarious liability imposed on commercial lessors by Vehicle and Traffic Law § 388"
    },
    {
      "source": "src_courtlistener_graham_v_dunkley",
      "locator": "50 AD3d at 58",
      "text": "We agree with the weight of precedent that the Graves Amendment was a constitutional exercise of congressional power pursuant to the Commerce Clause of the United States Constitution."
    }
  ],
  "version": 2,
  "revisions": [
    {
      "version": 2,
      "date": "2026-10-25",
      "summary": "Reviewed for source and accuracy."
    }
  ],
  "type": "relationship",
  "from": "case_ny_graham_v_dunkley",
  "title": "case_ny_graham_v_dunkley supports prop_us_mv_graves_rental_owner",
  "status": "VERIFIED",
  "jurisdiction": "us-ny",
  "domain": "torts.motor_vehicle",
  "verification": {
    "verified_on": "2026-09-30",
    "methods": [
      "Quoted passages compared word for word with the opinion text on CourtListener (cluster 5891633), fetched through its API on 2026-09-30; citations inside passages are replaced by ellipses.",
      "Citation 50 AD3d 55 resolves to this cluster through CourtListener's citation lookup; case name matches. Decision date (February 1, 2008) and slip opinion number read from the official reporter header as captured by a search engine; nycourts.gov refuses automated requests from this environment."
    ],
    "human_review_status": "reviewed",
    "reviewer": null
  },
  "url": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves",
  "cite_as": {
    "id": "rel_graham_supports_graves",
    "type": "relationship",
    "version": 2,
    "url": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves",
    "content_hash": "sha256:045c57195922868b3f0663242e80bc6c704f06a6a99464fe231fa5536c9fa2aa",
    "dataset_version": "2026.10.25"
  },
  "trust": {
    "authority_level": "intermediate_appellate",
    "source_type": "courtlistener",
    "primary_source": false,
    "verified": true,
    "verification_date": "2026-09-30",
    "source_freshness": "2026-09-30",
    "temporal_status": "timeless",
    "conflict_status": "none_known",
    "human_review_status": "reviewed",
    "provenance_complete": true
  },
  "applicability": {
    "as_of": "2026-11-04",
    "applies": true,
    "temporal_status": "timeless",
    "reason": "Follows the record it belongs to.",
    "status": "VERIFIED"
  },
  "graph": {
    "outgoing": [],
    "incoming": []
  },
  "provenance": {
    "passages": [
      {
        "source": "src_courtlistener_graham_v_dunkley",
        "locator": "50 AD3d at 58",
        "sha256": "sha256:e376602a72d4182bf6f6b6c56359980948792f2b613fbcf562a2ff71a87f823c",
        "source_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5891633/graham-v-dunkley/",
        "retrieved": "2026-09-30"
      },
      {
        "source": "src_courtlistener_graham_v_dunkley",
        "locator": "50 AD3d at 58",
        "sha256": "sha256:88b451e2c9e5c274153638de3a212c064e2afe67f21acb500a0843c4d4c4b37c",
        "source_url": "https://www.courtlistener.com/opinion/5891633/graham-v-dunkley/",
        "retrieved": "2026-09-30"
      }
    ]
  },
  "links": {
    "html": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves",
    "json": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves.json",
    "markdown": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves.md",
    "current": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves",
    "versions": [
      "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves/v/1",
      "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/relationship/rel_graham_supports_graves/v/2"
    ],
    "schema": "https://agents.newyorkeverydaylawreference.com/schema/relationship.json"
  }
}